It was then time for an encounter between two distinct personalities, the calm Boogz and the excitement train Joke. It was the Mut 25 coins game with the lowest scoring at halftime, as Boogz outnumbered Joke 7-3. The second quarter started completely Joke and Boogz, however at the end of the third quarter, Boogz returned by throwing the ball for three points, then added an incredible user-lurkINT to bring the ball back into the field goal zone. Boogz added three points to make it 17-17 however, the final laughter would be with Joke when he decided to win the game with an incredible field goal that he scored himself and beat Boogz 20-17.

The final game in the quarterfinals make Problem against Volterax. In various instances, Volterax had drawn criticism for his "overuse" of the swerve. It's a bug that a receiver controlled by the user pushes into the route and then returns out in the form of a "swerve" move, causing the opponent to become virtually unusable. However, Problem is an top Madden player and was up to do any situation. Problem didn't face any issues with Volterax since he was well-prepared for the deep pass, and was able to intercept Volt when he attempted to make the swerve work and still attempting to block the ball to Chris Johnson. Problem led 17-7 at halftime and never looked back, leaving Volt down by 30-13.

The semi-finals included Skimbo who had not won a live contest play SpotMePlzzz who was hoping to become the first player to be the first to win both events. Both teams showed up in a buy mut coins game that went all back and forth in the first quarter of football. Skimbo's Moss played play after play, however SpotMe scored a touchdown from Skimbo through a user interception at the goal line with only 1:27 remaining in the second. The game would conclude 14-14. The adjustments to the halftime time were done by Skimbo who score two more touchdowns to win the game from SpotMePlzzz to 28-14.